Airbnb Hosts: Is It Time to Call It Quits?
Thinking about quitting Airbnb hosting? You’re not alone. With shifting regulations and an increasingly competitive market, many hosts are wondering if it’s still worth it. After more than a decade in the short-term rental industry, I’ve seen these challenges evolve—and I know there’s no one-size-fits-all answer.
Before making any big decisions, it’s important to take a step back and evaluate your options. From navigating new rules to overcoming burnout, there are key factors to consider that could reshape your approach—or even reignite your passion for hosting.
Let’s dive into why some hosts are rethinking their Airbnb journey, explore potential alternatives, and uncover strategies to help you make the best choice for your future.
We’ve rounded up all of our Airbnb Hosting Must-Haves right here in our Amazon Store. Click here to grab everything you need to curate your property and start earning 5-star reviews.
Why Hosts Consider Quitting Airbnb
- Why Hosts Consider Quitting Airbnb
- The Impact of New Taxes and Fees
- Alternatives to Quitting Airbnb Hosting
- Making the Decision: To Quit or Not to Quit
- Conclusion
Why Hosts Consider Quitting Airbnb
Running an Airbnb business isn’t always easy. Here’s why many hosts consider calling it quits:
Regulatory Pressures
Dealing with changing regulations is a major headache for Airbnb hosts. Cities across the globe are implementing strict rules and imposing significant fines on short-term rental properties.
For instance, New York City introduced regulations in 2023. These rules make hosts register with the city and only let them rent rooms in their primary residence while present, banning entire-home rentals under 30 days and impacting many hosts’ business models.
These kinds of regulations put a lot of pressure on Airbnb hosts, adding another layer of stress on an already tasking responsibility. These are just some of the reasons people are quitting Airbnb.
Increasing Costs
Operating an Airbnb can be costly, and expenses are rising. Property maintenance, cleaning fees, higher utility bills, and insurance premiums all eat into profits.
Platforms like Airbnb are also increasing their service fees. Hosts feel squeezed, making them question if it is worth it.
With your checking account taking hits, it may be time to analyze if the cost is truly worth it. Be sure to understand what is happening with the trends to see what is truly impacting your profits.
Managing your Airbnb finances the right way can make a huge difference in your profitability and peace of mind. One of the smartest moves you can make as a host is setting up a dedicated business banking account. It helps you track expenses, streamline taxes, and keep your personal and rental income separate. Want to learn how the right banking strategy can maximize your Airbnb profits? Check out our guide to business banking for hosts right here!
Market Saturation
Listing a basic apartment and watching bookings roll in? Those days are often gone. More people are starting Airbnb businesses, making the competition tough.
Oversaturation leads to lower occupancy rates and pricing pressures. Hosts constantly fight to stand out and stay profitable, causing many people to look for alternative options outside of hosting.
Adding social media may help some to reach a different audience that you wouldn’t normally reach. But keep in mind, social media takes a lot of effort, so this should be considered.
Guest Expectations and Demands
Travelers now have high expectations, seeking hotel amenities with a homey feel. Meeting these demands can be both exhausting and expensive.
High-speed Wi-Fi, smart home features, gourmet coffee, and luxury toiletries—the list of “must-haves” grows. Hosts invest more time and money in their Airbnb properties to try and keep up with the evolving customer expectations.
These ever growing demands cause more work for hosts. This may cause them to evaluate if the return is worth it.
Burnout and Personal Stress
Being an Airbnb host is demanding. Late check-ins, cancellations, and difficult guests affect mental health and personal life.
Many hosts feel “on call,” unable to disconnect from their rental business. This imbalance causes many to consider quitting Airbnb hosting.
It can also cause a lot of unwanted and unneeded stress to a host’s life. So for many it’s an easy answer to move on and quit Airbnb altogether.
The Impact of New Taxes and Fees
New taxes and fees significantly challenge Airbnb hosts. These costs impact the bottom line, pushing some to consider quitting.
The California Example
California’s proposed SB 584 bill exemplifies this issue. It introduces a 15% tax on short-term rentals, on top of the existing transient occupancy tax.
For hosts in places like Palm Springs, this increases guest costs. Some worry it makes their properties less competitive than hotels.
Copyright © laws can vary widely depending on the location of your Airbnb property. Make sure that you are following the guidelines set in place.
The Ripple Effect
The California bill is one example of a larger trend. As cities and states tap into platforms like Airbnb, hosts face similar challenges.
These burdens impact Airbnb profitability. It might be the final factor pushing them to quit.
These burdens are not likely to stop any time soon. Business Insider has noted the regulatory landscape continues to grow with no slow down in sight.
Alternatives to Quitting Airbnb Hosting
Before quitting completely, explore alternatives. Here are a few options:
Pivot to Mid-Term or Long-Term Rentals
If short-term rentals are tough, consider longer stays. Mid-term (30+ days) or long-term leases offer stable income with less management.
This works well with new regulations. Stays over 30 days often avoid these rules.
You can even potentially earn extra cash if you have it set up correctly to handle long-term stays. Consider looking at ways to convert your properties. If you’re feeling the challenges of short-term rentals or want to create more stability in your hosting income, midterm rentals could be the perfect solution! Hosting for 30+ days can attract reliable guests, reduce turnover, and help you navigate local regulations more easily. Curious if midterm rentals are a good fit for your business? Check out our guide on midterm rental hosting strategies right here!
Optimize Your Pricing Strategy
Before quitting, re-evaluate your pricing. Use dynamic tools like PriceLabs to adjust rates based on demand and events.
Are you using a credit card to pay for the costs of your business? You may want to check if it is a rewards credit card that earns points or other benefits.
You could even open a small business banking account to better organize and run your business. Take the needed steps today.
Focus on Direct Bookings
Reducing reliance on platforms cuts fees. Creating a direct booking website and building a repeat guest base helps maintain profits. Also, you don’t have to follow Airbnb’s privacy policy.
Consider getting travel insurance to help with any hiccups that might occur. Also consider your privacy choices.
This may also get more former Airbnb guests to return, but this time under your own terms and rules outside of Airbnb. This can cut down significantly on stress.
Upgrade Your Property
In saturated markets, stand out with upgrades. Add amenities, improve decor, or offer unique experiences.
Consider different ways to attract all sorts of people working remotely, such as highlighting a proper work from home setup in your Airbnb listing. This includes adding desks and other things that are suitable for remote work.
If you took out a balance transfer credit card previously and have an outstanding balance, look at options to make use of the interest free period to free up some more cash for these kinds of improvements. You want to make sure you have balance transfer opportunities before signing up though.
Want to make sure your Airbnb is stocked with everything guests need for a 5-star stay? A well-prepared rental leads to better reviews, happier guests, and more bookings! Grab our free Airbnb Essentials Hosting Checklist to ensure you have all the must-haves covered. Download it now right here! 🚀🏡
Outsource Management
If daily demands are draining, hire a property manager. It reduces workload and stress, though cuts into profits. You can keep track of their payments easily with small business tools that are easy to use.
Having someone else do tasks like managing check-ins could save a couple hours per day for yourself. These are all things to consider before making the decision to completely quit Airbnb.
Make sure your management has a solid and easy way to deposit earnings into your checking accounts. This will save you the hassle of constantly having to follow up with them to make sure things are getting done on time.
Making the Decision: To Quit or Not to Quit
Deciding to continue or quit is personal. Here are some things to consider:
Financial Analysis
Perform a financial analysis. Calculate true profits after expenses and compare to alternatives. Use personal finance software to keep track of your financial health.
Are you on track with your personal finance? Make sure to review it consistently to make informed decisions.
It could also be a good opportunity to evaluate savings accounts. Some accounts, like UFB Direct, offer better rates. Be sure to compare. Check out a UFB Direct bank review to see if they are right for you.
Time and Effort
Evaluate time and effort spent. Is it worth it, or a burden? Review to see if you will get a solid return on time spent on your Airbnb units.
Keep track of all expenses to properly monitor your Airbnb business to get the insights you need. It is much harder to make decisions when all the information is not clear and easily seen.
Consider all the options to help run things efficiently. The easier it is, the less likely a host will want to move on from their vacation rental.
Future Outlook
Consider future regulations and market saturation. Decisions should consider current and future trends to be ready. This could potentially make it’s hard on those looking to hold on for the future.
Monitor business today to stay informed on trends that can potentially hurt reasons people choose to continue running an Airbnb. Look at resources like the Dow Jones to understand where the industry is trending and going towards.
Staying informed will make it much easier to make a decision if it’s time to quit or not. Stay consistent.
Personal Goals
Reflect on personal and financial goals. Does hosting align, or are resources better spent elsewhere? Do not quit if you see that hosting Airbnb is aligning well.
Evaluate what goals you have with your rental property and the direction it is going. If your goals change, this may change your mind on hosting.
For example, are you looking to sell your property soon and need help getting a down payment? If that is the case, it could be worth continuing to host so that you can get the maximum amount of cash.
| Pros of Continuing | Cons of Continuing |
|---|---|
| Potential for high income | Increasing regulations and taxes |
| Flexibility and control | Time-consuming management |
| Meeting new people | Market saturation and competition |
| Property appreciation | Potential for difficult guests |
Takeaways
Quitting is a big decision. While challenges have increased, opportunities exist for those who adapt. This is a major change to your lifestyle, so it shouldn’t be taken lightly.
Explore all options before deciding. Pivot, optimize, or stand out. You could also consider opening a money market account, sometimes called market accounts, to earn more on the extra money your property is generating.
What works for one host may differ for another. Base decisions on your circumstances and goals. If you have a credit card, make sure you are on top of your credit scores so you are well prepared.
If quitting is right, have a plan. Transition to long-term rentals, sell, or find another use. Have your bank account prepared for major transitions.
The key is making an informed decision aligned with your goals. If you utilize tools like credit monitoring, you should have the right kind of insights to move forward and make a decision.
The short-term rental market changes, but adaptable hosts can thrive. So adapt to stay on top and potentially avoid being a host that decides to give up their properties and move on to something else entirely.
Calling All Hosts: The Hosting Handbook
If you loved this post we invite you to check out our one-stop-shop solution for hosts everywhere —the Hosting Handbook! While you can download all the easy to consume, step-by-step tips we use in our own hosting business and create the ultimate “book” the Hosting Handbook is so much more than that! If you’ve consumed or content for years (or just met us!) this is the reference guide for all the amazing and tactical tips we have for running a profitable and, more importantly hospitable, short-term rental. How do we price for pets? How do we fold our towels? What sheets do we buy? How do I purchase a short-term rental? All these questions (and more!) can be answered in the Hosting Handbook! Check it out now!
Happy Hosting!
show comments
HIDE comments