Why Your Airbnb Listing Might Be in Trouble (and You Don’t Even Know It) (Episode 491)

The Airbnb Feature You’re Not Checking (But Should Be)

If bookings have slowed or your property seems buried in search results, it might be time to dig into a little-known section of your Airbnb dashboard: the Listing Issues tab.

Hosts Sarah and Annette recently discovered this feature when one of their beautifully maintained properties was flagged by Airbnb. The issue? A guest tried to bring kittens—despite their clearly stated “dogs only” policy. Even though they handled the situation with care and refunded the guest, Airbnb marked it as a “forced cancellation,” triggering a warning on their account.

That experience—and another involving a guest upset about not staying in a shared space—prompted this week’s episode, which breaks down what Airbnb’s listing issues mean and why they matter.

Here are some of the biggest takeaways:

  • Listing issues aren’t always obvious. They might come from AI, not human feedback.
  • Private reviews count. Even if it doesn’t show up publicly, it could impact your ranking.
  • Your PMS might show red/yellow/green lights. Those indicators reflect listing health and may hint at hidden demerits.
  • Words matter. Even saying “cancel” in your messages can trigger Airbnb’s bots.

Sarah and Annette’s advice? Take extreme ownership. Review your listing language, house rules, and communication style regularly. Check the listing issues tab weekly. And above all—don’t rely solely on Airbnb. Use this as your sign to diversify where and how you’re getting bookings.

Because one platform should never control your entire business.


Download a transcript of this episode.

Resources:


#STRShareSunday

@12southcarriagehouse

Tucked in the heart of Nashville’s 12 South neighborhood—and with a sister property in Pigeon Forge—@12southcarriagehouse delivers charm in every detail. But what really caught our eye? The custom souvenir pencils labeled “The Sweet Retreat,” created as a playful nod to the host’s childhood collection. These thoughtful, personal touches leave a lasting impression and set your space apart. From standout branding to small keepsakes, this is hosting done right.

Planning a trip to Nashville or Pigeon Forge? Add 12 South Carriage House to your must-stay list.

We would love to feature YOU! Submit your property for our next #STRShareSunday at strshare.com.

Together, Annette & Sarah are the dynamic duo behind the wildly popular podcast Thanks For Visiting, co-creators of the Hosting Business Mastery Method, & seasoned short-term-rental hosts.

Meet Your Hosts

Reply...

keep listening...